InkdownInkdown
Start writing

Arpit Bhayani Blogs

336 filesยท168 subfolders

Shared Workspace

Arpit Bhayani Blogs
001 Ai Topological Sort

108-conflict-detection

Shared from "Arpit Bhayani Blogs" on Inkdown

Multi-Master Replication - Why Conflicts Happen

Source: https://arpitbhayani.me/blogs/conflict-detection Date: 2021-11-28

Understand conflicts in multi-master databases - Learn how to detect and resolve data inconsistencies for reliable systems.

Every multi-master replication setup comes with a side-effect - Conflicts. Conflict happens when two or more database accepts conflicting updates on the same record. We say that the updates are conflicting when we are unable to resolve them to one value deterministically. In this essay, we talk about conflicts and understand what they are, how to detect them.

Conflicts

Say we are building an online book store allowing users to purchase books at the click of a button. Like any e-commerce application, even ours has a , which acts as a staging area for everything the user shops for. The user likes a book, adds it to the cart, and proceeds to pay once the shopping is done, proceed to payment. When a user adds a book to the cart, this operation can never be forgotten or rejected - as it will result in loss of revenue and a very poor user experience.

001-ai-topological-sort.md
tldr.md
002 Temporal Primer
002-temporal-primer.md
tldr.md
003 Rag Production
003-rag-production.md
tldr.md
004 Structure Of Llm Chat
004-structure-of-llm-chat.md
tldr.md
005 How Llms Work
005-how-llms-work.md
tldr.md
006 Monolith Is Distributed System
006-monolith-is-distributed-system.md
tldr.md
007 Defensive Databases
007-defensive-databases.md
tldr.md
008 Bm25
008-bm25.md
tldr.md
009 Join Algorithms
009-join-algorithms.md
tldr.md
010 Venting At Work
010-venting-at-work.md
tldr.md
011 Half Life
011-half-life.md
tldr.md
012 Multi Paxos
012-multi-paxos.md
tldr.md
013 Mysql Replication Internals
013-mysql-replication-internals.md
tldr.md
014 Bloom Filters
014-bloom-filters.md
tldr.md
015 Clock Sync Nightmare
015-clock-sync-nightmare.md
tldr.md
016 Kafka Partitions
016-kafka-partitions.md
tldr.md
017 Product Quantization
017-product-quantization.md
tldr.md
018 Qkv Matrices
018-qkv-matrices.md
tldr.md
019 Deleted Production
019-deleted-production.md
tldr.md
020 How Llm Inference Works
020-how-llm-inference-works.md
tldr.md
021 Blocking Queues
021-blocking-queues.md
tldr.md
022 Heartbeats In Distributed Systems
022-heartbeats-in-distributed-systems.md
tldr.md
023 Cassandra Writes
023-cassandra-writes.md
tldr.md
024 Redis Replication
024-redis-replication.md
tldr.md
025 Arrogant People At Work
025-arrogant-people-at-work.md
tldr.md
026 Cdn Content Replication
026-cdn-content-replication.md
tldr.md
027 Cant Fix Everything Day One
027-cant-fix-everything-day-one.md
tldr.md
028 Emotions At Work
028-emotions-at-work.md
tldr.md
029 Grpc Http2
029-grpc-http2.md
tldr.md
030 Meetings With No Agenda Are A Waste Of Time
030-meetings-with-no-agenda-are-a-waste-of-time.md
tldr.md
031 Growth Is Not About Doing Everything
031-growth-is-not-about-doing-everything.md
tldr.md
032 Career Longevity Vs Job Hopping
032-career-longevity-vs-job-hopping.md
tldr.md
033 Stay Relevant At Higher Salary Levels
033-stay-relevant-at-higher-salary-levels.md
tldr.md
034 Why Consensus
034-why-consensus.md
tldr.md
035 Database Deadlocks
035-database-deadlocks.md
tldr.md
036 Cpu Cache Locality
036-cpu-cache-locality.md
tldr.md
037 Eventual Consistency
037-eventual-consistency.md
tldr.md
038 Dns Udp Tcp
038-dns-udp-tcp.md
tldr.md
039 Masters
039-masters.md
tldr.md
040 Empathy Makes Great Engineers Unstoppable
040-empathy-makes-great-engineers-unstoppable.md
tldr.md
041 Good Mentors Build People
041-good-mentors-build-people.md
tldr.md
042 Always Have Back Burner Projects
042-always-have-back-burner-projects.md
tldr.md
043 Before You Push Back Know What Youre Standing On
043-before-you-push-back-know-what-youre-standing-on.md
tldr.md
044 Be The One They Can Count On
044-be-the-one-they-can-count-on.md
tldr.md
045 How Much People Bet On You
045-how-much-people-bet-on-you.md
tldr.md
046 How To Get Leadership To Say Yes To Your Project
046-how-to-get-leadership-to-say-yes-to-your-project.md
tldr.md
047 Dont Let Your Best Ideas Die In Silence
047-dont-let-your-best-ideas-die-in-silence.md
tldr.md
048 Be Someone Others Want To Work With
048-be-someone-others-want-to-work-with.md
tldr.md
049 Dont Fall For Xy Problem Ask Right Questions
049-dont-fall-for-xy-problem-ask-right-questions.md
tldr.md
050 Biggest Lie Startups Tell Engineers
050-biggest-lie-startups-tell-engineers.md
tldr.md
051 Promotions Are Proactive Not Reactive
051-promotions-are-proactive-not-reactive.md
tldr.md
052 Not Enough To Be Right Learn To Be Heard
052-not-enough-to-be-right-learn-to-be-heard.md
tldr.md
053 No One Ships Alone
053-no-one-ships-alone.md
tldr.md
054 Not Every Mistake Needs A Correction
054-not-every-mistake-needs-a-correction.md
tldr.md
055 Build Influence At Work
055-build-influence-at-work.md
tldr.md
056 Your Soft Skills Arent Soft At All
056-your-soft-skills-arent-soft-at-all.md
tldr.md
057 Experience Before Forming Opinion
057-experience-before-forming-opinion.md
tldr.md
058 Curiosity And High Bias For Action
058-curiosity-and-high-bias-for-action.md
tldr.md
059 Worklog
059-worklog.md
tldr.md
060 Mistakes And Growth
060-mistakes-and-growth.md
tldr.md
061 Own It Instead Of Sweeping It Aside
061-own-it-instead-of-sweeping-it-aside.md
tldr.md
062 Dont Wait Step Up
062-dont-wait-step-up.md
tldr.md
063 Temporary Fix Is Permanent
063-temporary-fix-is-permanent.md
tldr.md
064 Interview Bias And What Sets You Apart
064-interview-bias-and-what-sets-you-apart.md
tldr.md
065 Saying This Isnt My Problem Is A Problem
065-saying-this-isnt-my-problem-is-a-problem.md
tldr.md
066 Okr
066-okr.md
tldr.md
067 Miscommunication
067-miscommunication.md
tldr.md
068 When In Doubt Code It Out
068-when-in-doubt-code-it-out.md
tldr.md
069 Follow Up Without Annoying People
069-follow-up-without-annoying-people.md
tldr.md
070 Lead Projects That Land
070-lead-projects-that-land.md
tldr.md
071 Abstract Thinking Skill Next Decade
071-abstract-thinking-skill-next-decade.md
tldr.md
072 We Engineers Suck At Task Estimation
072-we-engineers-suck-at-task-estimation.md
tldr.md
073 Shiny Object Syndrome In Tech
073-shiny-object-syndrome-in-tech.md
tldr.md
074 3p
074-3p.md
tldr.md
075 Leverage The Equilibrium
075-leverage-the-equilibrium.md
tldr.md
076 On Demand Container Loading In Aws Lambda
076-on-demand-container-loading-in-aws-lambda.md
tldr.md
077 Sql Has Problems We Can Fix Them Pipe Syntax In Sql
077-sql-has-problems-we-can-fix-them-pipe-syntax-in-sql.md
tldr.md
078 Nanolog A Nanosecond Scale Logging System
078-nanolog-a-nanosecond-scale-logging-system.md
tldr.md
079 Best Resource Is Mythical
079-best-resource-is-mythical.md
tldr.md
080 Wtf The Who To Follow Service At Twitter
080-wtf-the-who-to-follow-service-at-twitter.md
tldr.md
081 Know A Lot
081-know-a-lot.md
tldr.md
082 Out Of Syllabus
082-out-of-syllabus.md
tldr.md
083 Negotiate The Offer
083-negotiate-the-offer.md
tldr.md
084 Never Bad Mouth Your Ex Exployer
084-never-bad-mouth-your-ex-exployer.md
tldr.md
085 Culture Fit
085-culture-fit.md
tldr.md
086 Quantification In Resume
086-quantification-in-resume.md
tldr.md
087 Hiring Is Unfair
087-hiring-is-unfair.md
tldr.md
088 Questions For Interviewers
088-questions-for-interviewers.md
tldr.md
089 Collaboration Communication
089-collaboration-communication.md
tldr.md
090 Out Of Vicious Interview Cycle
090-out-of-vicious-interview-cycle.md
tldr.md
091 Pitch Projects Not Ideas
091-pitch-projects-not-ideas.md
tldr.md
092 Read Design Docs
092-read-design-docs.md
tldr.md
093 Read Rca Docs
093-read-rca-docs.md
tldr.md
094 Start Generalist
094-start-generalist.md
tldr.md
095 Do Not Rely On Summaries
095-do-not-rely-on-summaries.md
tldr.md
096 Structure Your Design Interviews
096-structure-your-design-interviews.md
tldr.md
097 Title Inflation
097-title-inflation.md
tldr.md
098 Find Your Own Project
098-find-your-own-project.md
tldr.md
099 Six Pointers To Crack Coding And Design Interviews
099-six-pointers-to-crack-coding-and-design-interviews.md
tldr.md
100 Keep Yourself Unblocked
100-keep-yourself-unblocked.md
tldr.md
101 Genetic Knapsack
101-genetic-knapsack.md
tldr.md
102 Pseudorandom Number Generation Lfsr
102-pseudorandom-number-generation-lfsr.md
tldr.md
103 How Indexes Work On Partitioned And Sharded Data
103-how-indexes-work-on-partitioned-and-sharded-data.md
tldr.md
104 Some Data Partitioning Strategies For Distributed Data Stores
104-some-data-partitioning-strategies-for-distributed-data-stores.md
tldr.md
105 Data Partitioning
105-data-partitioning.md
tldr.md
106 Leaderless Replication
106-leaderless-replication.md
tldr.md
107 Conflict Resolution
107-conflict-resolution.md
tldr.md
108 Conflict Detection
108-conflict-detection.md
tldr.md
109 Multi Master Replication
109-multi-master-replication.md
tldr.md
110 Monotonic Reads
110-monotonic-reads.md
tldr.md
111 Read Your Write Consistency
111-read-your-write-consistency.md
tldr.md
112 Handling Outages Master Replica
112-handling-outages-master-replica.md
tldr.md
113 Replication Formats
113-replication-formats.md
tldr.md
114 Replication Strategies
114-replication-strategies.md
tldr.md
115 Master Replica Replication
115-master-replica-replication.md
tldr.md
116 Durability
116-durability.md
tldr.md
117 Isolation
117-isolation.md
tldr.md
118 Atomicity
118-atomicity.md
tldr.md
119 Consistency
119-consistency.md
tldr.md
120 Architectures In Distributed Systems
120-architectures-in-distributed-systems.md
tldr.md
121 Mistaken Beliefs Of Distributed Systems
121-mistaken-beliefs-of-distributed-systems.md
tldr.md
122 Fork Bomb
122-fork-bomb.md
tldr.md
123 Chained Operators Python
123-chained-operators-python.md
tldr.md
124 Taxonomy On Sql
124-taxonomy-on-sql.md
tldr.md
125 The Weird Walrus
125-the-weird-walrus.md
tldr.md
126 Fully Persistent Arrays
126-fully-persistent-arrays.md
tldr.md
127 Persistent Data Structures Introduction
127-persistent-data-structures-introduction.md
tldr.md
128 Constant Folding Python
128-constant-folding-python.md
tldr.md
129 String Interning Python
129-string-interning-python.md
tldr.md
130 Recursion Visualizer Python
130-recursion-visualizer-python.md
tldr.md
131 Flajolet Martin
131-flajolet-martin.md
tldr.md
132 2q Cache
132-2q-cache.md
tldr.md
133 Israeli Queues
133-israeli-queues.md
tldr.md
134 1d Terrain
134-1d-terrain.md
tldr.md
135 Jaccard Minhash
135-jaccard-minhash.md
tldr.md
136 Ts Smoothing
136-ts-smoothing.md
tldr.md
137 Lfu
137-lfu.md
tldr.md
138 Morris Counter
138-morris-counter.md
tldr.md
139 Slowsort
139-slowsort.md
tldr.md
140 Bitcask
140-bitcask.md
tldr.md
141 Phi Accrual
141-phi-accrual.md
tldr.md
142 10x Engineer
142-10x-engineer.md
tldr.md
143 Decipher Repeated Key Xor
143-decipher-repeated-key-xor.md
tldr.md
144 Decipher Single Xor
144-decipher-single-xor.md
tldr.md
145 Python Iterable Integers
145-python-iterable-integers.md
tldr.md
146 Inheritance C
146-inheritance-c.md
tldr.md
147 Rum
147-rum.md
tldr.md
148 Consistent Hashing
148-consistent-hashing.md
tldr.md
149 Python Caches Integers
149-python-caches-integers.md
tldr.md
150 Fractional Cascading
150-fractional-cascading.md
tldr.md
151 Copy On Write
151-copy-on-write.md
tldr.md
152 Midpoint Insertion Caching Strategy
152-midpoint-insertion-caching-strategy.md
tldr.md
153 Fsm Python
153-fsm-python.md
tldr.md
154 Bayesian Average
154-bayesian-average.md
tldr.md
155 Sliding Window Ratelimiter
155-sliding-window-ratelimiter.md
tldr.md
156 Idf
156-idf.md
tldr.md
157 Better Programmer
157-better-programmer.md
tldr.md
158 Python Prompts
158-python-prompts.md
tldr.md
159 Rule 30 Cellular Automata
159-rule-30-cellular-automata.md
tldr.md
160 Function Overloading
160-function-overloading.md
tldr.md
161 Isolation Forest
161-isolation-forest.md
tldr.md
162 Image Steganography
162-image-steganography.md
tldr.md
163 Long Integers Python
163-long-integers-python.md
tldr.md
164 I Changed My Python
164-i-changed-my-python.md
tldr.md
165 Benchmark And Compare Pagination Approach In Mongodb
165-benchmark-and-compare-pagination-approach-in-mongodb.md
tldr.md
166 Mongodb Cursor Skip Is Slow
166-mongodb-cursor-skip-is-slow.md
tldr.md
167 Fast And Efficient Pagination In Mongodb
167-fast-and-efficient-pagination-in-mongodb.md
tldr.md
168 Making Http Requests Using Netcat
168-making-http-requests-using-netcat.md
tldr.md
Shopping Cart

Say the user had books B1, B2, B3 in the cart already, and this state of the cart is consistent in both the master nodes Master 1 and Master 2. Say the user just added book B4 to the cart, and this request went to Master 1 which makes the local state of Master 1 to be B1, B2, B3, B4, while Master 2 continues to remain at B1, B2, B3.

Now, say the user added another book B5 to the cart, and this request went to Master 2. The request reached Master 2 before the changes from Master 1 got a chance to be propagated. Since the master node will accept the write the local state of Master 2 becomes B1, B2, B3, B5 while state of Master 1 is B1, B2, B3, B4.

Conflict in real world - shopping cart

Thus, we have two versions of the same shopping cart. When the two master nodes syn, they will detect a conflict that needs to be resolved. The resolution to this conflict is not as simple as replacing one with the other because replacement will lead to the loss of information.

The correct way to address this situation is that we will have to merge the two versions of the cart such similar to the set union. This is a classical case of Conflict Detection and Resolution, and the possible resolution strategy depends on the application and context.

In the above example, we saw a custom conflict resolution strategy in a real use case, but resolving conflicts is not always possible. For example, when two users book the same seat for the same movie, the requests go to two different Masters, and both successfully acknowledge the user confirming the seat. Thus, in this case, the same seat for the same movie show was allotted to two different users. But, since we already sent the confirmation to the user, there is no way to resolve this conflict without giving one of the users an extremely poor experience.

Conflict Detection

Detecting conflict is simple when we have a single Master node, given that we can serialize all the writes going through it - the second write waits while the first one executes.

But when we have a multi-master setup, all the Master nodes can accept the writes and successfully apply them to their copy of data. When the changes asynchronously propagate to other Master nodes, the conflict is detected. Given that both the writes requests were successfully accepted and applied, there is no way to communicate the conflict to the client.

Conflict Detection - Async Replication

Given that it becomes tough to do something after we detect a conflict when the master-master replication is asynchronous, a possibly easier way out would be to make replication synchronous. In this setup, when one of the Master nodes accepts write, let is successfully apply to its own copy of data and synchronously propagate the write to other Master nodes before responding to the client.

Conflict Detection - Sync Replication

Although this approach solves the problem of detecting conflicts and getting a chance to resolve them, it makes the setup lose its main advantage of allowing multiple masters to accept writes in parallel.